Justia Nebraska Supreme Court Opinion Summaries
State ex rel. Hilgers v. Herman
A criminal case was initiated in Sarpy County, Nebraska, against an individual accused of first degree sexual assault of a child. At the preliminary hearing in county court, a deputy county attorney prosecuted the case, and the judge found probable cause to bind it over to district court. Defense counsel did not raise any issues about ex parte communications or conflicts of interest at this stage. After the case moved to district court, a different deputy county attorney was assigned, and the original prosecutor was no longer involved. Defense counsel later alleged, for the first time in district court, that the deputy county attorney had engaged in improper ex parte communications with the county court judge during the preliminary hearing. She sought to call the deputy county attorney as a witness, but ultimately did not do so.The district court, on its own initiative, considered these allegations and the purported appearance of impropriety, and appointed a special prosecutor from the Attorney General’s office, disqualifying the Sarpy County Attorney’s office from further participation. The Sarpy County Attorney’s office objected, arguing there was no evidence supporting a conflict of interest or improper conduct. The court denied motions to reconsider, and the defense never presented evidence of misconduct or called the deputy county attorney to testify. The district court eventually found the motion to quash the subpoena moot.The Nebraska Supreme Court reviewed the district court's actions in an original quo warranto proceeding brought by the Attorney General and Sarpy County Attorney. The Court held that the district court abused its discretion in appointing a special prosecutor because no evidence was presented supporting a disqualifying conflict of interest under the relevant statute. The appearance of impropriety alone was insufficient, and the conflict was not shown to affect the entire county attorney’s office. The Court ordered judgment of ouster, reinstating the Sarpy County Attorney’s office to the prosecution and removing the Attorney General’s office as special prosecutor. View "State ex rel. Hilgers v. Herman" on Justia Law
Hinrichsen v. RCTS Properties
RCTS Properties, L.L.C. purchased a building from the Hinrichsens in 2010, financing $100,000 of the purchase price with a promissory note secured by a deed of trust. The note required monthly installment payments, which RCTS made for just over a year before ceasing payments after May 2012. A member of RCTS, Messersmith, personally guaranteed the debt and filed for bankruptcy in August 2012. The Hinrichsens filed a proof of claim in the bankruptcy for the balance due, but did not expressly demand immediate payment or state they were accelerating the debt. Messersmith’s personal liability was discharged, and the Hinrichsens received no payment.Upon RCTS’ demand for reconveyance of the deed of trust in 2022, the Hinrichsens refused and later demanded payment in 2023, including default interest and referencing possible acceleration. In 2024, the Hinrichsens initiated judicial foreclosure. RCTS defended on statute of limitations grounds, contending that the limitations period began in 2012 due to acceleration triggered either by the bankruptcy filing or the proof of claim. The District Court for Buffalo County found that neither event constituted clear and unequivocal action by the Hinrichsens to accelerate the debt under Nebraska law, and entered a decree of foreclosure for the full amount due, including all missed installments.On appeal to the Nebraska Supreme Court, RCTS renewed its arguments. The Nebraska Supreme Court held that neither Messersmith’s bankruptcy nor the Hinrichsens’ proof of claim constituted an acceleration of the debt for purposes of starting the statute of limitations. The Court also held that the 10-year statute of limitations for foreclosure actions applies, not the 5-year statute for contract actions, and that all missed installments could be included in calculating the indebtedness. The Supreme Court affirmed the district court’s decision. View "Hinrichsen v. RCTS Properties" on Justia Law
Posted in:
Bankruptcy, Real Estate & Property Law
State v. Prestige
The appellant was serving prison sentences at the Nebraska Correctional Center for Women and became involved in a physical altercation with another inmate, Ashley Wood. The incident occurred inside Wood’s cell in the early hours of the morning, a location Prestige was not permitted to enter under prison rules. Testimony at trial showed Prestige entered the cell and engaged in a fight with Wood. Correctional officers and other inmates described Prestige as the aggressor, and there was evidence Prestige admitted to striking Wood, though Prestige later denied this admission and claimed she acted in self-defense after being attacked. Tensions between Prestige and Wood were documented prior to the incident.The District Court for York County held a jury trial at which Prestige was convicted of second degree assault and sentenced as a habitual criminal. Prestige, represented by new counsel, appealed, raising claims that the district court failed to conduct a hearing on the voluntariness of her post-incident statements, wrongly denied a self-defense instruction, and erred by not granting a mistrial when technical difficulties allegedly impeded her ability to participate in the trial remotely. She also raised several claims of ineffective assistance of trial counsel related to these alleged errors and other pretrial and trial conduct.The Nebraska Supreme Court held that the district court was not required to initiate a voluntariness hearing sua sponte absent a motion by the defense and that the evidence did not warrant a self-defense instruction because Prestige unjustifiably placed herself in harm’s way by entering the other inmate’s cell. The court found no reversible error regarding the technical difficulties, as there was no showing of actual prejudice. Claims of ineffective assistance of counsel were either insufficiently pled, conclusively refuted by the record, or required additional facts not in the record. The Supreme Court affirmed the district court’s judgment. View "State v. Prestige" on Justia Law
Posted in:
Criminal Law
State v. Saunsoci
Police officers stopped a driver late at night after observing her vehicle traveling above normal speed, lacking visible license plates, and making unusual movements when pulling over. The driver admitted she did not have a license and appeared confused, struggling to answer questions. The passenger was reportedly highly intoxicated. The officers suspected impairment and decided to conduct field sobriety tests. Due to snow and cold weather, they transported the driver a few blocks to a nearby parking garage attached to police headquarters, where they administered sobriety tests and a preliminary breath test. After completing the tests, the officers arrested the driver and took her inside the headquarters for a breath alcohol analysis.The District Court for Douglas County reviewed the defendant’s motion to suppress evidence, which argued that the transport to the parking garage constituted an unlawful arrest lacking probable cause. The court held a hearing, reviewed testimony and video evidence, and found that the officers made a lawful traffic stop supported by reasonable suspicion. The court concluded that the transport to the parking garage for field sobriety tests, motivated by safety and weather concerns, did not convert the investigative detention into an arrest. After a bench trial on stipulated facts and evidence, the court found the defendant guilty of driving under the influence, fourth offense, and imposed sentence.The Nebraska Supreme Court applied a two-part review: clear error for factual findings, and independent review for legal conclusions regarding Fourth Amendment protections. The court held that the officers’ transport of the defendant to a parking garage for field sobriety testing, under these circumstances, did not elevate the detention to an arrest requiring probable cause. The investigatory detention remained lawful, and the district court’s decision overruling the motion to suppress was affirmed. View "State v. Saunsoci" on Justia Law
Posted in:
Constitutional Law, Criminal Law
Robinson v. Boyd
The appellant pleaded no contest to multiple charges in 2019, including stalking, tampering with evidence, and possession of a deadly weapon by a prohibited person. The information alleged that he possessed a firearm while under a valid harassment protection order but did not explicitly state that he was knowingly violating the order, an essential element under the relevant statute. He was sentenced to consecutive terms of imprisonment, with the sentence for possession of a deadly weapon by a prohibited person falling within statutory limits.After serving his first two sentences, the appellant filed an application for a writ of habeas corpus in 2024 in the District Court for Lancaster County. He argued that his sentence for possession of a deadly weapon was void because the information failed to allege an essential element of the offense and the factual basis at the plea hearing did not cure this defect. The district court ordered the appellees to respond and held a hearing. It concluded that a court has jurisdiction to sentence a defendant even if the information omits an essential element, and that an insufficient factual basis does not affect the court’s power to impose a sentence. The writ was disallowed and the application denied.On appeal, the Nebraska Supreme Court reviewed the district court’s order de novo. The court held that the omission of an essential element in an indictment, information, or complaint does not render a sentence void or deprive the sentencing court of jurisdiction. Such defects do not permit collateral attack by habeas corpus, as long as the court had jurisdiction over the offense and the defendant, and the sentence was within statutory limits. Accordingly, the Nebraska Supreme Court affirmed the district court’s judgment denying the writ. View "Robinson v. Boyd" on Justia Law
Posted in:
Criminal Law
In re Special Knox Cty. Atty. Begley
After a new audio and visual system was installed in a county courthouse, including microphones for security and meeting purposes, certain county board members discovered that audio feeds were accessible during closed meetings and private sessions. This led to concerns about privacy and prompted the board to hire a special attorney and deputy to investigate potential breaches of courthouse security and possible violations of law. A district court determined that a conflict of interest prevented the special attorney from conducting a related criminal investigation and instead appointed the Nebraska Attorney General’s office as a special prosecutor. The court ordered that investigative materials be sealed. After the special prosecutor declined to file charges, the special prosecutor’s appointment was terminated, and additional records summarizing the investigation were also sealed.Subsequently, the board’s own civil investigation led to discipline or discharge of several employees, including a former county attorney whose name had been reported for possible professional misconduct. This former county attorney later moved in the original miscellaneous court file to unseal the records related to the special prosecutor’s investigation, arguing that the documents could be relevant to ongoing litigation and reputational interests. The special prosecutor did not oppose unsealing, but the board, represented by the special attorney, objected, arguing lack of subject matter jurisdiction and insufficient grounds for unsealing. The District Court for Knox County found it had jurisdiction, determined good cause existed, and ordered the records unsealed.On appeal, the Nebraska Supreme Court reviewed whether it had appellate jurisdiction over the district court’s order. The court held that the order to unseal records in a special proceeding was not a final, appealable order because the board failed to demonstrate that any substantial right was affected by unsealing. Therefore, the Nebraska Supreme Court dismissed the appeal for lack of jurisdiction. View "In re Special Knox Cty. Atty. Begley" on Justia Law
Posted in:
Civil Procedure, Government & Administrative Law
Koch v. City of Sargent
The plaintiff brought suit against a municipal defendant, raising several claims related to alleged procedural violations during a city council meeting, including purported breaches of Nebraska’s Open Meetings Act. The plaintiff sought to void actions taken at that meeting. The defendant responded by moving to dismiss the complaint for failure to state a claim. After a hearing, the District Court for Custer County dismissed most of the plaintiff’s claims but allowed five to proceed. Subsequently, the plaintiff withdrew two causes of action, and the court held a trial on the remaining three. The court determined it lacked jurisdiction over certain claims and found the plaintiff had not met the burden of proof, ultimately denying all requested relief.Following the district court’s entry of a judgment in April 2026, the plaintiff appealed. The Nebraska Court of Appeals summarily dismissed the appeal, concluding it lacked jurisdiction because, in its view, the district court had not rendered a judgment in compliance with Nebraska statutory requirements. The Court of Appeals relied on the absence of a “single written document” as prescribed by statute and cited the Nebraska Supreme Court’s prior decisions interpreting those requirements.The Nebraska Supreme Court reviewed the dismissal for plain error. It held that the district court had rendered judgment by signing a single written document that denied all relief and stated judgment was entered against the plaintiff and for the defendant as to each cause of action. The Supreme Court clarified that a judgment exists without explicit dismissal language, provided all relief is addressed in one signed document. The Court reversed the Court of Appeals’ dismissal and remanded the case for further proceedings, concluding the appellate court had jurisdiction over the appeal. View "Koch v. City of Sargent" on Justia Law
Posted in:
Civil Procedure, Government & Administrative Law
State v. Robinson
The case involves a defendant who was convicted of first degree murder and related weapons offenses. After his conviction and sentencing were affirmed on direct appeal—with a modification to his life sentence—he pursued postconviction relief in the District Court for Douglas County. The court denied some of his claims without a hearing and others after an evidentiary hearing. The defendant later claimed he was denied his right to appeal the denial of postconviction relief due to the clerk’s negligence. The district court initially dismissed this claim for lack of jurisdiction, but the Nebraska Supreme Court reversed and remanded. Upon remand, the district court found official negligence had caused the lost appeal and reinstated the appeal, which was ultimately affirmed by the Nebraska Supreme Court. The defendant’s subsequent federal habeas petition was denied.In April 2025, the defendant filed another motion for postconviction relief and a motion for a new trial, which were denied by the District Court for Douglas County on May 5, 2025. The order was sent to his former attorneys, not directly to him. Unaware of the order, he filed duplicate motions, which were again denied. The district court later recognized he had not been notified of the earlier orders and mailed them directly to him. He then filed a motion for reconsideration, claiming it was timely due to delayed notice, and the district court accepted it as being within the ten-day period for a motion to alter or amend.The Nebraska Supreme Court reviewed whether the appeal was timely. The court held that the district court lacked authority to extend the statutory time for appeal based on delayed notice, absent evidence supporting official negligence. Because the motion for reconsideration was not filed within ten days of the relevant order and no proper motion to vacate was filed with supporting evidence, the notice of appeal was untimely. The Nebraska Supreme Court dismissed the appeal for lack of jurisdiction. View "State v. Robinson" on Justia Law
Posted in:
Criminal Law
State v. Coleman
The case involved a fatal shooting that occurred in Omaha, Nebraska, on November 8, 2023. The defendant was charged with first degree murder and use of a deadly weapon in connection with the death of a 17-year-old victim. Evidence at trial included eyewitness testimony that the defendant shot the victim after a group attack, statements allegedly made by the defendant admitting to the shooting, forensic evidence linking shell casings to a recovered handgun, DNA analysis suggesting the defendant could be a contributor to DNA found on the gun’s magazine and shell casings, and a video found on the defendant’s phone showing him with a similar firearm about a week before the shooting.The case was first tried in the District Court for Douglas County. The defendant filed pretrial motions to exclude the cell phone video and related expert comparison testimony, as well as to exclude DNA evidence analyzed using probabilistic genotyping software, arguing these were irrelevant and unduly prejudicial. The district court overruled these motions, found the evidence relevant and more probative than prejudicial, and admitted both the video and DNA evidence at trial. The jury found the defendant guilty on both counts, and the court imposed consecutive sentences of 80 years to life for murder and 40 to 50 years for the weapon offense. The defendant appealed, challenging the evidentiary rulings, sufficiency of the evidence, and the length of his sentences.The Nebraska Supreme Court reviewed the case. It held that the district court did not abuse its discretion in admitting the cell phone video, the expert’s comparison testimony, or the DNA evidence, finding each relevant and not unfairly prejudicial. The Court found sufficient evidence supported the convictions and ruled that the sentences, while lengthy, were within statutory limits and considered appropriate factors, including the defendant’s age. The convictions and sentences were affirmed. View "State v. Coleman" on Justia Law
Posted in:
Criminal Law
In re Estate of Todd
After Douglas G. Todd died in January 2025, his son Chadd B. Todd sought informal probate of Douglas’ 1984 will, which left Douglas’ property to his sons. Judy Sheets, who had lived with Douglas in a long-term relationship but was not married to him, objected, claiming Douglas had executed a two-page handwritten will in February 2021 leaving his estate to her. Judy admitted that, apart from Douglas’ signature and date, the material provisions of the 2021 document were written in her handwriting but asserted Douglas had instructed her what to write.The County Court for Lincoln County reviewed competing summary judgment motions from Chadd and Judy regarding the validity of the 2021 document as a holographic will. The court concluded there were no genuine issues of material fact. It ruled that the 2021 document was not a valid holographic will of Douglas because the material provisions were not in his handwriting. Alternatively, the court found that the 2021 document did not express testamentary intent. Judy appealed this decision.The Nebraska Supreme Court reviewed the county court’s grant of summary judgment de novo. It analyzed whether the 2021 document, purported to be a joint will, qualified as a valid holographic will under Nebraska law, which requires the signature, material provisions, and date to be in the handwriting of the testator. The Court held that when the material provisions of a purported joint will are in the handwriting of one party, it cannot be a valid holographic will of the other party, even if the other party signs it. Thus, the 2021 document was not a valid holographic will of Douglas, and the Court affirmed the county court’s decision. View "In re Estate of Todd" on Justia Law
Posted in:
Trusts & Estates